We saved our pennies and sent out two (of the three) hubcaps to be repaired and re-chromed. We sent them to Courtesy Metal Polishing, on recommendation of other Scotty folks and after finding good reviews online.
Today I got home from a meeting to find a delivery notice taped to our door – so we scrambled around and got the package held at the carrier’s warehouse, then just braved a windy storm to go pick them up.
And wow – was it all worth it! They look like the messed up, old, dinged, painted things we sent in were secretly replaced with perfect brand new hubcaps. Seriously – an amazing transformation. The third one (on the right, in case it’s not obvious!) is too far gone for chroming this time around – and we’re out of cash – but perhaps someday we’ll get sophisticated enough to figure out what to do with it. I mean, does a spare tire really need a fabulous hubcap?

One of these things is not like the other...

Two shiny hubcaps. Hard to get a photo that does them justice.
Next up: we need to paint the Scotty lettering – time for more research.
Just so happened, we were packing up the hubcaps to send them in right after I had spent a serious amount of time trying to scrub the bejeesus out of the original sink strainer basket – we actually gave up on it, but after seeing how chintzy new replacements were, I just tossed it in with the hubcaps with a note. Could it be chromed too? And it came back all shiny and clean enough for the kitchen.

Sink strainer - also sparkly!
Which reminds me – we still have to hook up the sink. Once the snow melts…